Was Jesus a Martyr? [open conversation]



These days we're doing a chapter-by-chapter discussion of Gonzalez's Church History books...what I thought was boring in Seminary makes for lively conversation in the church! 

So the conversation came up about the early Christian martyrs and trying to define what 'martyr' meant.  We waffled between two definitions:
  1. Someone who dies for a cause  *OR*
  2. Someone who dies because of a cause
Then from the leftmost table (the troublemakers) came the question:

Was Jesus a Martyr?

So, which is Jesus?
  1. Did Jesus die for his cause?   *OR*
  2. Did Jesus die because of his cause?
So, sound off.  Which of the above statements is closer to your idea of Christ?

To me, this is an important question.   Because how you answer may rely on your  understanding of what Jesus' death means (ie. atonement).
  1. If Jesus died for his cause, then there's a higher likelihood that you hold a redemptive atonement theory (penalty-satisfaction or substitutionary) because you place a high meaning on Jesus' death.
  2. If Jesus died because of his cause, then there's a higher likelihood that you hold to an incarnational atonement theory (moral-influence or incarnational) because you place a high meaning on Jesus' life (and a prophetic life inevitably leads to death).
So, which is it? 

Did Jesus die for or because of his cause? 

And does either of those make him a martyr?

Discuss.

1 comments:

johnmeunier October 13, 2009 at 7:25 AM  

Interesting questions. I love the troublemakers, as long as they are in your discussion group and not the one I lead. :)

I'm trying to think of the NT answers to these questions. I'm not sure Jesus would interpret his death as martyrdom. It was not for what he was a witness to, but who he was - which is not an inconsequential distinction. We can be witnesses to Christ. But he simply is Christ.

The Epistles seem to read his death as largely redemptive. I was reading Colossians 1:13 just last night and it is still in my mind.

Post Your Comment (click here for a pop-up comment form)

Questions? Read the "Four Responsibilities of Commenting"
Jazz hands! ~Jeremy

Comment via FriendConnect

Favorite Sites

Latest from the Methoblog

Search the Methodist World

Want to see more United Methodist responses to a topic? Enter the topic into this search engine and search ONLY methodist blogs and sites!

UMJeremy's shared items

Disclaimer: all original content reflects the personal opinions of Rev. Jeremy Smith, not the doctrinal positions or statements of the United Methodist Church local and global.
all linked or quoted content represent the source's opinions, not Jeremy or the United Methodist Church.

  Blogger Template © Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP